eHam Logo

Community
 Home
 eHam.net Home
 Articles & Stories
 Contesting Wiki
 Speakout
 Strays
 Survey
 My Profile

Resources
 This Week's Contests
 Classified Ads
 Contest Links
 Product Reviews



Contest Lists
 3830
 CQ-Contest
 CT-User
 NA-User
 SD-User
 TRLog
 VHFcontesting
 WriteLog

Other Lists
 Amps
 AntennaWare
 Propagation
 RFI
 RTTY
 TenTec
 TopBand
 TowerTalk
 Yaesu

 Mailing List FAQs


Site Information
 About This Site
 Contesting.com Team

Contesting Online Survey

Survey Question Current Survey Question

do you consistently miss the same sections in the ARRL SS every year

Recent Surveys

Which rig do you use to contest?
2014-09-21


Do you have plans to upgrade/overhaul your contest station this summer?
2014-03-10


How much you spended on your Contest Station ? ( as near as possible, with all costs included: location, antennas, rigs, accs, cabling, etc )
2014-01-22


How were condx for the 2013 CQWW CW at your QTH?
2013-11-25


How were condx for the 2013 CQWW SSB at your QTH?
2013-10-28


View All Survey Questions

Have a good idea for a Contesting Online Survey question?
Enter your idea!


Monoband antennas or Multi-band antennas? What do you use?
  Posted: Jun 01, 2006   (278 votes, 14 comments) by K3LR

  Monobanders
  Tribanders
  Quad Band
  Dual Band
  Other
    (278 votes, 14 comments)
Survey Results
Monobanders 34% (95)
Tribanders 37% (102)
Quad Band 6% (18)
Dual Band 2% (5)
Other 21% (58)

Survey Comments
Two towers
For many years I used a TH6 and 2 el KLM 40 on a 70 ft tower, shunt fed the tower on 160 and had a four element 80 (top half of a K3LR array) surrounding the tower.

Have moved up to two towers, 80 ft 45G with 2 el Optibeam on 40, modified 204BA at 90 ft and 58 ft of 25G with a 5 el 10 (modified 6el KLM) and a 4 el 15 (modified Cushcraft) at 68 ft. I shunt feed the 80 ft tower for 160 and surround it with the same 4 el 80. No WARC antennas yet, probably a multi band dipole on the small tower.

This setup out performs my previous setup by a good margin.

Posted by w0uo on June 26, 2006

Mono- or Multi- band antenna?
For VHF, I use mono-band yagi's. For lower HF, mono-band wires; for 40 mtrs, a Force 12 EF-240; and for the upper end of HF, a Hy-gain TH6DX and a Force 12 C31XR.

Posted by k5er on June 20, 2006

Pentabander
My TH-11DX is a temporary antenna but it is performing so well I think I'll leave it up in the air (70')

Posted by K0RC on June 17, 2006

Both
Being a "one tower, one radio" station, I use a Force-12, C3S triband, and a Cushcraft 40-2-CD. I never expect to overcome the "one radio" disadvantage, but I still have as much fun, as possible.

Posted by K4WW on June 12, 2006

Obsolete
I use 5 el monobanders in a Christmas tree... but if I were doing it again, I would use the new computer designed interlaced yagis... 2 dimensions are less trouble thn 3 dimensions!

Posted by VE2DC on June 10, 2006

Tribanders
Force12 Tribanders:

http://www.freewebs.com/ad6wl/photogallery.htm

73, Jim
AD6WL

Posted by AD6WL on June 9, 2006

Tri-bander - Best Price / Performance
When you've got a one tower station that can only hold a single beam, it's hard to beat the tribander.

If I could afford the land/towers/antennas, I'd certainly go with an array of monobanders, but I maintain that the step up from tribander to monobander isn't as great a leap as that from low wires to the tribander.

Posted by AA4LR on June 8, 2006

7-Bander!
I use a Mosley Pro67C-3 that I won as a door prize at the 1996 Dayton Hamvention. It is resonant on 7 bands, 40-10 meters and has worked DXCC on each of them plus mixed Honor Roll. I guess if the question was referring only to contests, it's a quad-bander. It's like FREE pie and chips!

Posted by AA8LL on June 7, 2006

Tribanders, but would like monobanders
Being a one tower station, I believe I've optimized as best I can for SO2R:
3 TH7s - top 2 phased and bottom one for second radio.

Of course, monobanders would be preferable, but not an option unless I want to install another tower. I get beat in the pileups by a consistent group, but manage to do OK when the contest is over.

Posted by w2up on June 5, 2006

low power SO2R
if you're doing low power SO2R "3 band monobander Quad" is a great space saving antenna... of course you will need band pass filters... works great for me at 9A7P...
http://www.rkp.hr/active/components/com_ponygallery/img_pictures/najpopularnija-seoska-antena.jpg

Posted by 9a6xx on June 5, 2006

What's the difference?
I think that if VE5ZX's antenna is fed with 3 feedlines, and could be operated on 2 or 3 bands at once, it is a 3 band monobander. But if it has only a single feedline, then it is a a tri-bander.

Posted by k3yd on June 4, 2006

Wire Antenna Tip
Being stuck with all wires, I've found its advantageous to use non-resonant, gain antennas (example: stacked EDZs) fed with open wire line to the ground then moving trough L-networks and baluns to acheive 50 ohms unbalanced. Why? Non-resonant antennas do wonders for SO2R interstation interference mitigation. (Poos man's monobanders)

Posted by N4GG on June 4, 2006

Monobanders
For no compromise SO2R, Monobanders are the only way to go. I can Run with 4/4 on 20 and S & P with 8 el or 3 el on 15. Triband stacks force a compromise between full strength run and S & P on a different band, assuming you can switch one out of the stack. With the cost of many of these tribanders, you can often get more bang for less buck with some nice 3, 4, or 5 el monobanders.

N1UR

Posted by N1UR on June 1, 2006

What is the difference?
I have a C31XR. It is composed of three interlaced monobanders.

Is this antenna a three band monobander or a tribander?

Posted by VE5ZX on June 1, 2006

To post a comment, you must be logged in.

If you are not a member, become one now!